"We're Not Looking to Be Your Long-Term Partner."
Yes, I said this to a prospect. Here's why I don't regret it.
By Evan Boyer
It was 6:25 in the morning on Friday in August. I sat in front of my computer, bleary-eyed, recording a Loom of a pitch deck I had finished putting together 5 hours before.
I had a couple notes on the screen, but when I got to the slide about pricing, I paused for a couple beats too long.
"Fuck it," I said in my head as I gathered the courage to slap my entire agency background in the face. "Just be real."
Then, out loud, I projected these words, "We're not looking to be your long-term partner."
The shock. The horror. But what I meant was simple. We want to provide value, not lock you into a retainer just for the sake of it. If you've convinced someone you're valuable, they're going to want to be proven right fairly quickly. That's doubly true if budgets are tight.
And if they're not convinced, keep our number and call when you need us.
Frankly, I've never had the guts to approach it this way, or been allowed to say something so...out there. But what I'm finding in entrepreneurship is decisions like that are the result of years of brewing thoughts, emotions and experiences under the surface. These are mine.
Win With an Underdog Mindset
Growing up, I was smart, but I never made the Gifted & Talented program. Athletic, but usually not All-Star game material. In my professional career, it took me almost ten years to build the kind of resume I needed to be considered for a position at a global agency.
My secret sauce was always that instinct to do more with less. And most of the solo founders, small businesses and challenger brands that I like working with have that same instinct. They don't have unlimited resources. Their marketing budgets are lean, and if they're spending on PR, they want results fast. I'm motivated by that sense of urgency, and nothing makes me happier than nailing the assignment and moving on to the next.
Run the Program on a Real Structure
What's kept me in this industry for so long is the challenge and the satisfaction of proving what's possible without massive spend. Have I worked on multi-million dollar clients? Yes. But you don't need a giant budget to tell powerful stories. You need a clear narrative, strong delivery and a plan to scale it.
A lot of businesses miss the mark here. They jump straight to all the ads, events and glitzy campaigns without investing in the stories, anecdotes, and data points that make their brand story interesting.
It does take some legwork at the beginning to set that structure in place, but it doesn't take forever. And once you have a strong foundation, everything else gets easier. Media pitches land. Sales decks are sharper. Executives sound consistent and compelling. Without it, it's almost like building on sand.
If this work is done right, it should be pretty easy to carry this work forward. A tune up here or there, maybe a workshop or an in-person training, but not a "Hey, let's strip this thing down to the studs again" after six months.
The problem is, most aren't bold enough to build that foundation to begin with (it's hard!), and the results that follow are usually mediocre, strung out for a year or more, and everybody leaves the relationship wishing it had gone better.
Build the Habit. It's Harder Than It Looks
Anyone in this business will tell you, it's not enough to just have a story. I've been in so many annual planning sessions, narrative development workshops and media trainings where the thoughts in the room are flying, the binder full of messaging is dynamite (shout out Mitt Romney!), and then it collects dust.
The real work is in practice. Can your executives and sales team be comfortable delivering those messages in real conversations? Do they know how to pivot when questions go sideways, or how to reframe a tough topic into their strengths? Storytelling is like voice training: once it is well-enough developed, it's much more about repetition and structured practice than it is about working with the actual trainer.
Fit
If you're a sports fan, you might remember LeBron's infamous subtweet years ago, telling his All-Star teammate Kevin Love to "fit in," rather than "fit out." It's terrible direction for any agency partner, yet that's what ends up happening so often. By just "fitting in" and people-pleasing, so many agencies mistakenly think they're creating a situation where they become indispensable, or at least, keep the retainer wheel turning. They're mistaken.
Leaders PR is not in the business of being on anyone's payroll forever. If we can't help you, you shouldn't pay us. We exist to help business leaders uncover the stories that actually move their business forward, and to help them learn how to deliver those stories day in and day out.
Teach a man to fish, you know?
This article was first published on LinkedIn on September 9, 2025.

